Level 2 · Jazz

Trading Fours

Three bars of comping, one bar of solo — repeat

Duration · 25 min Focus · Form / Soloing
Prerequisites

Trading fours is a jazz performance convention: after the head and the main solos, the band takes turns soloing in four-bar increments. The horn plays four bars, the drummer plays four bars, the horn plays four, the drummer plays four. (You also get "trading eights" and "trading twos" — the duration changes, the principle doesn't.) It's a jazz-specific structural game built into the form.

Why four bars? Because the standard jazz form (the 32-bar AABA standard, the 12-bar blues) is built out of four-bar phrases, and trading fours respects that phrasing. Each four-bar trade is one phrase of the form. The soloing drummer is filling in for the horn during one of the form's natural phrases, then handing it back.

You can't really practise trading fours alone with a metronome — there's no horn to trade with. The practical workaround used in this lesson is the solo-bar template: comp for three bars, solo for one bar, comp for three bars, solo for one bar. The single solo bar is a stand-in for the band's four-bar phrase, scaled down for solo practice. Once that's automatic, you scale up — comp for four bars, then solo for four bars (Exercise 2).

The hardest thing about a four-bar solo is making it sound like a phrase, not a random fill. The traditional solution is motivic development: pick a small rhythmic idea (a "motive"), play it in bar 1, vary it slightly in bar 2, vary it again in bar 3, resolve it in bar 4. The idea is recognisable across all four bars because all four bars are versions of the same shape. Exercise 3 demonstrates this with a single 16th-note triplet motive.

1 — The Solo-Bar Template (3 + 1)
4/4 · swing 8ths · ♩ = 140 · 4-bar phrase
Three bars of comping (different snare position each bar) followed by one solo bar of straight 8ths on the snare. The hat-foot on 2 and 4 keeps going through the solo bar — that's important. The form is what you're holding when you let go of the time. Loop the four-bar phrase. The challenge is reentering the comp cleanly on bar 1 of the next loop after the solo bar.
2 — A Full 4-Bar Solo at Medium Tempo
4/4 · swing 8ths · ♩ = 140 · solo phrase
Bar 1 states on the snare, bar 2 answers on the toms, bar 3 mixes, bar 4 resolves to the ride to hand it back — hat-foot on 2 and 4 through everything. The moments that count: the FIRST hit of bar 1 and the FINAL hit of bar 4.
3 — Motivic Development: One Idea, Four Variations
4/4 · swing 8ths · ♩ = 140 · motivic solo
One motive — two 8ths + a quarter — in every bar; only the last note moves (high tom → mid tom → floor tom, inverting in bar 4). You have it when the four bars feel like one sentence rather than four separate ideas.
4 — Trading Yourself: Comp 4, Solo 4 (Loop)
4/4 · swing 8ths · ♩ = 140 · 8-bar phrase
Four bars of comp (two single-position figures), four bars of the Exercise 3 motive, looped — hat-foot marking 2 and 4 across all eight. Judge yourself only on the two handoffs: bar 4 into bar 5, and bar 8 back into bar 1. Everything else is preparation.
Move on when
  • 3-bar comp + 1-bar solo template (Ex 1) loops at ♩=140 with the comp returning cleanly each time
  • A 4-bar solo (Ex 2) starts and ends on beat 1 — no rushing the first hit, no overshooting the last
  • Motivic exercise (Ex 3): the same rhythmic idea is recognisable in all four bars of the solo
Listening 3 records

Listen for it

  1. 01

    Max Roach Sonny Rollins — Saxophone Colossus

    "Blue 7" — the iconic recorded trading-fours session.

  2. 02

    Tony Williams Miles Davis — Four & More

    Trading fours and twos at very fast tempos; Williams is articulate at every speed.

  3. 03

    Roy Haynes Chick Corea — Now He Sings, Now He Sobs

    Trios trading at the highest level of motivic development.