Modern Jazz Independence

Capstone — flexible swing, broken-time, melodic-snare

Duration: 35 min Focus: Phrasing & Form

This is the capstone of the jazz track. Everything from the previous nine lessons converges here: bop vocabulary, uptempo time, broken time, modal comping, comping vocabulary, free-jazz texture, post-bop independence, the Elvin triplet feel, the Williams quarter-note ride. Modern jazz drumming — the language of Brian Blade, Eric Harland, Marcus Gilmore, Jeff Watts, Bill Stewart, Antonio Sánchez — is a fluent recombination of all of it.

The exercises below are five concrete vocabulary studies. Three are paraphrased from structures in the 50 Phrases of Brian Blade collection — not the phrases themselves (those are Blade's transcribed work) but the structural ideas: a short anchor figure that returns; an 8th-note flurry that lands on a syncopated point; a snare-as-conversation device that responds to an implied soloist; the use of broken time as a stable groove rather than a special effect. The fourth uses a Carlos Vega-style flexible swing feel (from the 20 Transcriptions). The fifth puts everything together as a 12-bar form.

  • Phrase 1 — paraphrased from a Blade structural device: a short anchor figure (snare on the &-of-3) returning every two bars within otherwise improvised comping.
  • Phrase 2 — paraphrased from a Blade flurry-and-resolution device: an 8th-note triplet flurry on the snare that lands on the &-of-3 of the next bar.
  • Phrase 3 — paraphrased from a Blade kick-conversation device: kick on a syncopated point in bar 1, snare answering on the same point in bar 2.
  • Phrase 4 — Carlos Vega-style flexible swing 8ths: the same ride pattern played first with straight 8ths, then with deep triplet feel, in adjacent bars.
  • Phrase 5 — a 12-bar capstone combining all four phrases with broken time in bars 9–10.

1 — Phrase Study A: Anchor Figure (paraphrased Blade structure)

4/4 · swing 8ths · ♩ = 130
Anchor figure structure (paraphrased from the recurring-fragment device in the Blade phrases): the snare lands on beat 4 in bars 1 and 3 — that's the anchor. Bars 2 and 4 are improvised (varied snare placements). The repeating beat-4 hit gives the phrase an internal logic that the listener can track even though the comping is otherwise free.

2 — Phrase Study B: Flurry-and-Resolution (paraphrased)

4/4 · 8th-note triplets · ♩ = 120
Flurry-and-resolution structure (paraphrased — an 8th-note triplet flurry that lands on the &-of-3): bar 1 is normal ride. Bar 2: ride on beat 1, then six snare 8th-note triplets across beats 2 and 3, resolving to a strong accented snare-and-ride hit on the &-of-3. Bar 3 returns to the ride pattern. The flurry creates tension; the resolution is the snap on the &-of-3 — that placement is the whole device.

3 — Phrase Study C: Kick-and-Snare Conversation (paraphrased)

4/4 · swing 8ths · ♩ = 130
Kick-and-snare conversation structure (paraphrased — kick states a syncopated figure, snare answers it): in bar 1 the kick lands on the &-of-2, accented — that's the call. In bar 2 the snare lands on the &-of-2 (same beat-position, different voice) — that's the response. Two voices passing the same rhythmic figure between them. This is one of Blade's most-used phrasing devices and shows up across the 50 Phrases collection in many forms.

4 — Phrase Study D: Flexible Swing Placement (Vega-style)

4/4 · ♩ = 140
Same notated ride in all four bars; only the 8th placement moves. Bar 1: dead straight. Bar 2: standard swing. Bar 3: deep triplet feel (notated as triplets for clarity). Bar 4: standard swing again. Don't change the notes — change where they sit. That's the Vega flexibility.

5 — Capstone: 12-Bar Form (combine all four phrases)

4/4 · swing 8ths · ♩ = 130
The capstone. Bars 1–2: Phrase A anchor. 3–4: Phrase C — kick on &-of-2, snare answering on &-of-3. 5–6: Phrase B flurry. 7–8: Phrase D, bar 7 straighter, bar 8 swung. 9–10: broken time. 11–12: return and resolve with the Philly Joe lick. Once it runs, improvise your own placements inside the same 12-bar shape.
Move on when
  • Three Brian Blade-style anchor phrases (paraphrased structures from the 50 Phrases collection) memorized and deployable in a comping context
  • Flexible swing 8ths — can shift placement from straight-8th-feel to deep-triplet-feel within four bars without disrupting the form
  • Broken time within a 12-bar form: the form is preserved despite ride disappearing for whole bars
  • Melodic-snare conversation — a 4-bar exchange where snare and kick respond to each other as if they were two different soloists
Listening 4 records

Listen for it

  1. 01

    Brian Blade Brian Blade & The Fellowship Band — Season of Changes

    The bandleader on this record is the drummer, and he barely solos on it. Start with the opener, Rubylou's Lullaby, and follow how Blade shapes the tune from the kit rather than waiting for a feature.

  2. 02

    Eric Harland Charles Lloyd — Mirror

    Flexible swing 8ths within a single tune; deep-triplet to straight-8th and back.

  3. 03

    Marcus Gilmore Vijay Iyer Trio — Accelerando

    The trio's Human Nature is the Michael Jackson song, so you already know the melody they are pulling out of shape. Listen underneath it for Gilmore's broken grooves, then go to Actions Speak for his extended feature.

  4. 04

    Carlos Vega James Taylor — Hourglass

    Studio-precision flexible swing — listen to how Vega reshapes the same groove across choruses.