Other Topics

Odd Meters Beyond 7

9, 11, 13 — the meters past the comfort zone

Duration · 30 min Focus · Time / Meter
Prerequisites

Once you're comfortable in 5/4 and 7/8, the door opens to everything past them. Nine. Eleven. Thirteen. These meters look intimidating on paper but feel logical the moment you stop counting individual 8ths and start feeling groupings. A bar of 11/8 isn't eleven of anything — it's usually 3+3+3+2, four uneven groups in a recurring shape. Once the shape is in your body, the bar plays itself.

The trick that makes every odd meter approachable is the same: identify the small groupings, accent the start of each group, and trust the shape to repeat. Greek and Balkan folk musicians live in 7, 9, 11, and 13 the way most Western players live in 4 — not because they're counting harder but because they grew up dancing these shapes.

9/8 as 2+2+2+3 is the most common feel in modern progressive music: three even pairs followed by a long group. Soundgarden's "Spoonman" outros, Dream Theater bars, lots of fusion. 9/8 as 3+3+3 is the compound-time feel — think of three big beats, each subdivided into three 8ths. This is the dance-meter feel of a fast Balkan kalamatianos or the swung 9/8 of a Mediterranean folk groove. The same time signature, completely different body.

11/8 most commonly groups as 3+3+3+2 — three "long" groups and one "short" — and is the meter under tunes like "Outshined" (Soundgarden) and many Meshuggah-style prog passages. 13/8 splits a few ways; a useful default is 3+2+3+2+3 (long-short-long-short-long), which gives the bar a clear shape that returns on itself. The principle stays the same: group it, accent the group, repeat the shape until it's a single thing in your body.

The fourth exercise in this lesson drops a beat: a bar of 4/4 followed by a bar where one quarter-note is replaced by a quarter-note triplet. The tempo doesn't change, but the perceived bar length does — which is the simplest form of metric modulation. The same skill scales up to large-scale modulations between meters; it starts here, with one missing beat.

1 — 9/8 Groove (2+2+2+3)
9/8 · 8th = 200
Count: 1-2 / 3-4 / 5-6 / 7-8-9. The first three groups are pairs; the last is the long group of three. The most common error is treating the long group as another pair — the bar collapses to 8/8. Use the snare to mark group boundaries: snare on the start of group 2 (count 3) and group 4 (count 7). Bass drum kicks off group 1 and group 3. Loop until the long group feels like home, not like a stumble.
2 — 9/8 as 3+3+3 (Compound Feel)
9/8 · 8th = 240 · dotted-♩ = 80
Same time signature, completely different feel. Three even dotted-quarter beats, each subdivided into three 8ths. Count: 1-2-3 / 4-5-6 / 7-8-9, all groups equal. The hi-hat plays steady 8ths, the snare lands on beats 2 and 3 of the dotted-quarter pulse (count 4 and count 7). This is the dance-meter feel — Mediterranean folk, fast 9/8 jigs, certain prog tunes. Notice how a bar of 3+3+3 has a totally different gravity to 2+2+2+3.
3 — 11/8 Groove (3+3+3+2)
11/8 · 8th = 220
Count: 1-2-3 / 4-5-6 / 7-8-9 / 10-11. Three long groups and one short group at the end. Snare on the start of each group after the first (counts 4, 7, 10) so your ear hears the grouping change. The big mistake is letting the final 2-group stretch into another 3 — the bar collapses to 12/8. Practise by saying the count out loud for the first eight bars: the voice keeps the shape honest.
4 — 13/8 Groove (3+2+3+2+3)
13/8 · 8th = 220
Count: 1-2-3 / 4-5 / 6-7-8 / 9-10 / 11-12-13. The bar pulses long-short-long-short-long, a palindromic shape that returns on itself. Snare on the start of every group except the first; bass drum on count 1 and count 7 anchors the two halves of the bar. Once it loops, you'll feel the shape repeat as a single phrase, not as thirteen 8ths. 13/8 stops being odd the moment you stop counting it.
Move on when
  • 9/8 (2+2+2+3) groove holds at ♩ = 90 for two minutes with the long group never collapsing into 2
  • 11/8 (3+3+3+2) groove loops without losing the grouping
  • 13/8 (3+2+3+2+3) holds for one minute with each grouping clearly audible
Listening 3 records

Listen for it

  1. 01

    Soundgarden Spoonman / Outshined

    9/8 (2+2+2+3) and 11/8 (3+3+3+2) in commercial rock

  2. 02

    Dream Theater The Dance of Eternity

    Encyclopedia of odd-meter writing

  3. 03

    Don Ellis Live at Monterey

    33/16, 27/16 — odd meter as compositional language